Ramps vs trolley jack for oil change

[balancerider 773]

Thinking I want to DIY the oil change on the E91 320i I'm looking after atm - internet suggests that ramps are probably a better option than a jack. Any counter opinions for this?

[gjm 3258]

You should never work under a vehicle while it is only supported by a hydraulic jack. (Carefully written to avoid ambiguity or any reference to wring-doing that I may, or may not, have been guilty of at some point.)

I have some offcuts of 2" timber that I create ramps from and drive up on to so that the car is high enough to get under and access the drain plug, but not so high that the oil can be affected by a prevailing breeze and blown clear of the pan I use to catch stuff...

 

[Eagle 1677]

Yeah i don't think you could safety do an oil change on a E91 only using jack. Engine\drain is mounted quite far back.

[M3AN 4016]

As above, question is:

Ramp or jack + stands.

Answer is:

Jack + stands is more versatile, ramps are cheaper and quicker.

[nick496 269]

Yeah, I do it the gjm way on stock cars. Just drive them onto blocks, and there is enough space to reach all the way back to the drain plug. 

On the E30 I have to drive it onto blocks, then put the jack under it, put it on stands and then I'm good to go. 

And as M3AN says, if you're wanting to do more than just oil changes, the jack and stands give you way more options. 

[KwS 2429]

You'll probably find, depending on spec, you will have trouble getting an e91 on most commercial ramps as they are really steep and will hit the bumper. I've had mine for years but barely use them because of this. 

[jon dee 500]

Real men just park straddling the gutter and crawl under to do an oil change 

Cheers...

[KwS 2429]

2 hours ago, jon dee said:

Real men just park straddling the gutter and crawl under to do an oil change 

Cheers...

Drained straight into the gutter, right?

[jon dee 500]

3 hours ago, KwS said:

Drained straight into the gutter, right?

Yeah... nah... we don't do that round our way. Better to catch the old oil in a 10 litre bucket and let it stand somewhere quiet for a month. Then the black stuff sinks to the bottom and you can decant the clear oil off and use it again. Gotta recycle for the good of the environment  

Cheers...

[C-130 Hercules 571]

Old engine oil is perfect on wooden fences.